My first thought is it is either unconstitutional (which requires extensive and impossible actions by Congress &/or states to change), or requires a law change (Act of Congress).
My second thought is that it will motivate thousands of first, second and third generation immigrant citizens to get to the polls and vote against the Republican Party.
The 14th Amendment can not ever in any way be changed with an executive order. This president keeps making claims that he is above the Constitution.
Here's the 14th Amendment section 1 that shows that children born here are citizens: All persons BORN or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
The ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) which is made up of lawyers versed in our Constitutional Rights, immediately issued a response to Drump for his uneducated, wrong, and inflammatory claim that he will take away people's citizenship.
This is just a ploy to rev up his crazy base, and to make the rest of us just plain crazier than we already are. Don't waste energy on this folks. It's trump being an abuser. He can issue all the exec orders he wants, it's not gonna happen. Focus on voting and keeping calm. Don't let that monster rattle you, at least now with this nonsense.
I don't want to offend anyone, but I need to get this out of my system cause it will feel really good!
For the sake of argument, let's say Trump was able to change the constitution (we all know he can't). His grand-father was an illegal immigrant. He didn't want to join the German army for a war they were fighting at the time, so he ran to the US. That would mean, his father would not have been a US citizen therefore neither would he be.
So, if he was able to go ahead with that, would he know he would not be an American citizen? I don't think he's smart and aware enough to understand. And not being an American = can't be president!
Ironic, isn't it? Trump was a leader of the birther movement. Obama's mother was from long line of Americans. Even if his father's was Kenyan, Obama has more American blood in him than Trump could ever dream of having.
Please know there is nothing wrong about being an immigrant or being the child of an immigrant. On the contrary! More is added to our culture! I also am from a country of immigrants and proud of it! I may have had a little fun just now, going through Trump's genealogy, but I accept and respect his ancestry.
Sorry again but it felt good sharing this with you. I'm not American and I understand the US constitution better than he does! Let's pray for wisdom is sent to all the voters. Let's send our angels so they ensure the validity of each vote and is representing the true will of the people.
Love this, Bright Opal!!
His grand-father was an illegal immigrant. He didn't want to join the German army for a war they were fighting at the time, so he ran to the US. That would mean, his father would not have been a US citizen therefore neither would he be.
Didn't even realize Trumps own grandfather was an illegal immigrant.
I love that you let it all out! And yes, we're sick of it all, too.
But boy do we learn in the process!
Here's a link to an op-ed from today's Wash Post written by a former acting solicitor general and Kellyanne Conway's husband. It gives a great explanation about why trump's proposal is a lot of hot air. Don't worry peeps, this thing is going nowhere. It's just a distraction.
Andy Borowitz in the New Yorker did a story on Trump disqualifying himself for the presidency. I always have to do a double take each week when I read headlines from Borowitz. Even satire sounds true with Trump.
Trump's suggestion that he could do this by executive order is nuts. I was hoping that maybe this is more junk he's throwing at the wall to see if it sticks, but then reading today that Lindsey Graham says he'll propose legislation to do this if Trump doesn't just made my head -- and heart -- hurt.
As I said in another thread, I probably would no longer be an American citizen by Trump's thinking. Both of my parents were born in the U.S. but neither set of my grandparents (from Ireland and Germany/Hungary) were naturalized at the time my parents were born. So, therefore, I would not be a citizen either under this reasoning.
Ironically, I DO qualify for Irish citizenship through my grandparents. I've verified that in the past, but never did the paperwork. I may have to take another look at doing that if this insane idea proceeds. I love Ireland, and still have family there. I could happily spend my retirement years there, if necessary.
Pentagon sending 5,200 troops to the border in 'Operation Faithful Patriot' amid Trump condemnation of migrant caravan.
Want to call out the hate speech Trump is spouting about immigrants. Last night the Washington Post reported these statements from him at one of his rallies in Missouri:
Donald Trump: The Democrats want to continue giving automatic birthright citizenship to every child born to an illegal alien. Even if they’ve been on our soil for a mere matter of seconds. Hundreds of thousands of children born to illegal immigrants are made automatic citizens of the United States every year, because of this crazy lunatic policy that we can end.
And they’re all made instantly eligible for every privilege and benefit of American citizenship. All of you, you get nothing more than they do. They’re full citizens. And it’s costing us many, many billions of dollars a year. --Donald Trump
The Lies in this speech:
1. That this policy is from the Democrats. No, it's bedrock American policy that is part of the Fourteenth Amendment of the U .S. Constitution, adopted right after the Civil War. This policy is part of what makes America what it has prided itself in being.
2. That this policy is "a crazy lunatic policy." No, it's bedrock American policy that is part of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution, adopted and passed by a supermajority (two/thirds) of the U.S. Congress.
3. That the children of immigrants who are automatically granted citizenship because they are born here are "costing us many, many billions of dollars a year." Totally made-up. There is no data to support this.
This hate speech is unAmerican, discriminatory, monstrous, and a lie.
Cop Killer in Video Released by Sheriff Joe / https://politicalwire.com/topics/immigration/
Trump leaves a deep bruise on my soul every time he opens his mouth especially about these refugees. I had trouble sleeping last night after hearing his latest rants. The above story cheered me up some. Joe Arpaio was the guy who released this so called cop killer featured in the new ad. Oh, the irony.
TaG22, thanks for those articles. -- (1).That there is growing fear among Republican operatives that the campaign that Trump is mounting against immigrants will backfire and cause more people to get to the polls and vote against the GOP.
(2) That the uncle of White House political consultant Steven Miller said that the migrants remind him of his Jewish ancestors seeking asylum in the U.S.
(3). the Department of Defense informed the White House that the migrants posed no threat to national security.
Not sure if this is the right Immigration forum for me to post this:
The Supreme Court is hearing arguments today in a set of cases involving the legal status of DACA recipients. T**** tried to rescind this program seven months after taking office, but the lower courts blocked his action.
A decision on DACA is expected by this summer. I'd read that Congressional Repubs may be hoping that the high court will let them off the hook, and rule in favor of DACA.
Just a request to keep them in your prayers, and that justice will prevail.